Comments on: 29-31: Hahnemann’s Organon of Medicine http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/ Just another WordPress.com weblog Mon, 03 Mar 2008 17:57:00 +0000 http://wordpress.com/ hourly 1 By: rainbow9 http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-625 rainbow9 Sat, 09 Feb 2008 21:45:16 +0000 http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-625 No deception intended- when I started my blog, I ended up with two accounts, and when I came back to posting here I didn't originally realize that rainbow9 was replacing GaleG! hcn...what can I say...your attacks have been a gift to me- by showing me the contrast of what I did not want, you have helped me to understand more of what I do want. This has nothing to do with homeopathy any more- much bigger for me. I do wish you well. No deception intended- when I started my blog, I ended up with two accounts, and when I came back to posting here I didn’t originally realize that rainbow9 was replacing GaleG!
hcn…what can I say…your attacks have been a gift to me- by showing me the contrast of what I did not want, you have helped me to understand more of what I do want. This has nothing to do with homeopathy any more- much bigger for me. I do wish you well.

]]> By: HCN http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-624 HCN Sat, 09 Feb 2008 20:30:52 +0000 http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-624 Thank you, Gimpy. It is nice to know that the total lack of empathy for the suffering caused by quacks and total level of silly stupidity did not just suddenly increase, that they are from the same incredulous person (who once dared ask us if we had ever had to deal with sick children). Thank you, Gimpy. It is nice to know that the total lack of empathy for the suffering caused by quacks and total level of silly stupidity did not just suddenly increase, that they are from the same incredulous person (who once dared ask us if we had ever had to deal with sick children).

]]> By: rainbow9 http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-622 rainbow9 Sat, 09 Feb 2008 17:40:35 +0000 http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-622 Gimpy, you're a good guy. I am going to keep my thoughts now on my own blog. I agree that we have gotten of topic here, and I wish you all well. Gimpy, you’re a good guy. I am going to keep my thoughts now on my own blog. I agree that we have gotten of topic here, and I wish you all well.

]]> By: gimpy http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-621 gimpy Sat, 09 Feb 2008 11:21:00 +0000 http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-621 Just so everybody knows rainbow9 is GaleG. Can I urge you all to keep the discussion to the Organon and questions stemming from it (your philosophy may be discussed terms of this debate rainbow9/GaleG). I'm currently putting in 14 hour days at work at the moment so can't contribute as much as I'd like or moderate so please keep things civil. Just so everybody knows rainbow9 is GaleG. Can I urge you all to keep the discussion to the Organon and questions stemming from it (your philosophy may be discussed terms of this debate rainbow9/GaleG). I’m currently putting in 14 hour days at work at the moment so can’t contribute as much as I’d like or moderate so please keep things civil.

]]> By: M Simpson http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-620 M Simpson Sat, 09 Feb 2008 11:10:24 +0000 http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-620 Rainbow 9, there isn't a person on the planet who hasn't had many, many thoughts of anger, fear, lack, illness, disaster etc, nor is there anyone who hasn't had many, many thoughts of joy, hope, love, warmth, happiness etc. There is no-one who has never, ever been ill although there are people who have been ill their whole lives (genetic conditions which were present in the womb, long before the person had any thoughts of anything). Crediting people's highs and lows to their good and bad thoughts is like crediting them to their left and right hands. We all have them. Please don't take this the wrong way, but this blog is for discussion of the Organon from a 21st century perspective, it's not for people to talk hippy nonsense. Rainbow 9, there isn’t a person on the planet who hasn’t had many, many thoughts of anger, fear, lack, illness, disaster etc, nor is there anyone who hasn’t had many, many thoughts of joy, hope, love, warmth, happiness etc. There is no-one who has never, ever been ill although there are people who have been ill their whole lives (genetic conditions which were present in the womb, long before the person had any thoughts of anything).

Crediting people’s highs and lows to their good and bad thoughts is like crediting them to their left and right hands. We all have them.

Please don’t take this the wrong way, but this blog is for discussion of the Organon from a 21st century perspective, it’s not for people to talk hippy nonsense.

]]> By: Mini http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-616 Mini Sat, 09 Feb 2008 04:29:28 +0000 http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-616 I thought homeopathy might work, but the amount of furious back-pedaling, misdirection and wandering off into realms of metaphysical BS I have read here, has done more to convince me otherwise. Please do not defend something if you cannot find straight answers. I thought homeopathy might work, but the amount of furious back-pedaling, misdirection and wandering off into realms of metaphysical BS I have read here, has done more to convince me otherwise. Please do not defend something if you cannot find straight answers.

]]> By: Bill http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-615 Bill Sat, 09 Feb 2008 03:17:00 +0000 http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-615 rainbow9 there is a mind/body connection,but its not what you think it is. read Edward Shorter's book. rainbow9

there is a mind/body connection,but its not what you think it is.

read Edward Shorter’s book.

]]> By: rainbow9 http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-614 rainbow9 Sat, 09 Feb 2008 01:20:02 +0000 http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-614 One more time....people over time have habitual thoughts of anger, fear, lack, illness, disaster etc. that MAY show up on the physical level, sometimes many years later. They do NOT consciously choose to be ill...but without understanding the mind-body connection, they may fall ill. I would NEVER NEVER EVER blame the person- I only have compassion, hence my desire to learn and teach these concepts. It is much easier to clean up one's thoughts before it shows up on the physical level. I maintain that we DO have the choice about what thoughts we habitually choose, and our emotions will tell us whether we are choosing thoughts that are harmonious or not. One more time….people over time have habitual thoughts of anger, fear, lack, illness, disaster etc. that MAY show up on the physical level, sometimes many years later.

They do NOT consciously choose to be ill…but without understanding the mind-body connection, they may fall ill.

I would NEVER NEVER EVER blame the person- I only have compassion, hence my desire to learn and teach these concepts. It is much easier to clean up one’s thoughts before it shows up on the physical level.

I maintain that we DO have the choice about what thoughts we habitually choose, and our emotions will tell us whether we are choosing thoughts that are harmonious or not.

]]> By: hcn57 http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-613 hcn57 Sat, 09 Feb 2008 01:09:47 +0000 http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-613 So, according to rainbow9, Gloria Thomas chose to die from sepsis. I believe my anger is justified when you have wannabe doctors getting in over their heads, and causing harm. Just like the homeopath father of Gloria Thomas, who was so deluded that he skipped the Health Service appointment that would have provided real medical care to his daughter: http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2007/11/a_real_death_by_homeopathy.php Anger is justified when silly stupid people make silly stupid statements that excuse the pretend doctor, their sugar pills, and then blame the victim. The stupid, it burns. GaleG, I know you hate the idea of actually opening up a book and reading anything that is not in short little lines, but do yourself a favor and read some Oliver Sacks, like "The Man Who Mistook his Wife for a Hat". That book and some of the others include essays that explore some of those issues. You might accidently learn something. So, according to rainbow9, Gloria Thomas chose to die from sepsis.

I believe my anger is justified when you have wannabe doctors getting in over their heads, and causing harm. Just like the homeopath father of Gloria Thomas, who was so deluded that he skipped the Health Service appointment that would have provided real medical care to his daughter:
http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2007/11/a_real_death_by_homeopathy.php

Anger is justified when silly stupid people make silly stupid statements that excuse the pretend doctor, their sugar pills, and then blame the victim. The stupid, it burns.

GaleG, I know you hate the idea of actually opening up a book and reading anything that is not in short little lines, but do yourself a favor and read some Oliver Sacks, like “The Man Who Mistook his Wife for a Hat”. That book and some of the others include essays that explore some of those issues. You might accidently learn something.

]]> By: Boredstudent http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-612 Boredstudent Fri, 08 Feb 2008 23:01:36 +0000 http://organon.wordpress.com/2008/01/28/29-31-hahnemann%e2%80%99s-organon-of-medicine/#comment-612 rainbow9- others have already done a very good job of demolishing what, I fear, are your entirely serious posts but just for the record 'vengeance' is not an emotion. I'm not going to touch the rest of the English you've so appallingly mangled in an effort to sound profound but your 'philosophy' is offensive and I'd expect something more sophisticated and logical from an 8 year old. Sorry, rant over. Just wanted to ask a question- why is it that homeopathic remedies supposedly don't cause side effects? I'm with the scientists on this one so don't tell me it's because the pills are inactive but from a homeopath rationale how is it that a pill can affect your body, defeating strong diseases, but have no other apparent effect then the exact one intended? According to the like cures like basis if a healthy person take pill A it will produce the symptoms it cures. However homeopaths quite freely talk about having to adjust prescriptions because the right combination hadn't been arrived at- in such a case surely the 'wrong' pill with nothing to cure should have produced symptoms- a side effect? rainbow9- others have already done a very good job of demolishing what, I fear, are your entirely serious posts but just for the record ‘vengeance’ is not an emotion. I’m not going to touch the rest of the English you’ve so appallingly mangled in an effort to sound profound but your ‘philosophy’ is offensive and I’d expect something more sophisticated and logical from an 8 year old.

Sorry, rant over. Just wanted to ask a question- why is it that homeopathic remedies supposedly don’t cause side effects?

I’m with the scientists on this one so don’t tell me it’s because the pills are inactive but from a homeopath rationale how is it that a pill can affect your body, defeating strong diseases, but have no other apparent effect then the exact one intended?
According to the like cures like basis if a healthy person take pill A it will produce the symptoms it cures. However homeopaths quite freely talk about having to adjust prescriptions because the right combination hadn’t been arrived at- in such a case surely the ‘wrong’ pill with nothing to cure should have produced symptoms- a side effect?

]]>